Last reviewed: 31st May 2019
Wine auctions are simply a marketplace with well defined sets of rules that
allow sellers and buyers of uncommon and rare wines to negotiate a trading price
anonymously. As is often the case, a buyer will know more about the wine on
offer than the seller and the seller uses an auction to extract information
about what a buyer is willing to pay via the auction system. The value of
uncommon, rare and older wines depends on the tastes of the buyer and is known
only to the buyer and will change over time.
Whilst current release, retail wines are not normally found at specialist wine
auction houses, there is a growing class of auctions that are dealing now in distressed and excess current vintage stock that typically appeal
to the drink now class.
By comparison to the rest of the world, Australian wine auctions are miniscule
affairs, mainly trading in the higher end Australian wines such as Penfolds
Grange and Henschke Hill of Grace. The very limited amount of international wine
imported into the country over the years and the ever growing lake of
domestically produced fine wine limits Australia’s development on the world
stage of fine wine trading.
Search our online database of vintage wine prices
Specialist Wine Auction Houses
Wines for enthusiasts and collectors
The following are the leading, specialist wine auction houses in Australia with
national scope and frequent auctions with respectable volumes and turnover of
fine and rare wines. They mainly deal in mature, old and uncommon wines and with
reserves at recognised market prices, varying only slightly from auction house
to auction house.
One of the major differences between a specialist and general wine auctioneer is
that the specialist will give a guideline to the buyer on the historical value
of a wine (low or average price paid and sometimes high price paid) where the
general auction house uses RRP (recommended retail price) as a guideline for
buyers which can result in un-informed buyers paying as much as 40% more than
fair market price, resulting in a larger degree of regret from
winners
curse, which in turn affects the entire auction industry.
As well as being a clearing house for secondary market fine wines, specialist
wine auction houses can also be very strong brand advocates and influencers,
keeping brands and the memory of those wines in circulation for decades.
Wickman’s Fine Wine Auctions
Membership Cost: Free
Auction Frequency: Monthly
Buyer commission: 11% incl GST
Shipping Costs: $17 + insurance per carton.
Website: www.wickman.net.au
Founded in 2003 from a series of charity auctions, Wickman’s is an independent,
family business and offers a very personal wine auction experience, specialising in
the trading of rare and fine wines from private collectors. It is the only wine
auction house to offer guaranteed provenance (a history of how the wine has been
purchased and stored).
Oddbins Wine Auctions
Membership Cost: $22+ per annum.
Note: You must be a paid member before you can view the lots on offer
Auction Frequency: Monthly
Buyer commission: 15% incl GST
Shipping Costs: $16 + Insurance
Website: www.oddbins.com.au
Oddbins wines have been around since the early 90’s, Oddbins have set up a new online
bidding system and have increased the frequency of their auctions so that they
now have a budget and a fine wine section. You can view current auctions or past
catalogues after becoming a member.
MW Wines
Membership Cost: : $27+
Note: You must be a paid member before you can bid on the lots on offer.
Auction Frequency: Monthly
Buyer commission: 15% incl GST
Shipping Costs: $16 + Insurance
Website: www.mwwines.com.au
MW Wines are a supplier of old and rare wines since the late eighties, MW Wine
auctions are run
professionally and efficiently and offers a museum wine shop for those who have
no patience for wine auctions.
Langton’s Wine Auctions
Membership Cost: $33 per annum.
Note: You must be a paid member before you can bid on the lots on offer.
Auction Frequency: Weekly
Buyer commission: 16.5% incl GST
Shipping Costs: $10 to $15 per carton + insurance.
Website: www.langtons.com.au
Langtons
wines is Australia’s most influential leader when it comes to establishing
prices in the secondary wine market and was sold to the Woolworths chain (includes Dan
Murphy’s) in 2009. It operates frequent auctions, sourcing large amounts of
current release wines through its corporate networks. Langtons also publish the
Langtons Classification guide which attempts to classify Australian wines based
on past activity within the secondary wine market.
Sterling Wine Auctions
Membership Cost: Free.
Auction Frequency: Monthly
Buyer
commission: 15% incl GST
Shipping Costs: $20 + Insurance
Website: www.sterlingwine.com.au
The only
wine auction house based on the West coast (Perth), Sterling has been operating
since the early 90’s and often has access to many of the great Western
Australian wines.
General & Non Traditional Auctioneers
Budget and distressed wines
There are many auction houses in Australia that deal in art, white goods and
office and house contents; and of course wine. Wine auctions are just one aspect
in a general auctioneer’s portfolio.
Most of the wines on offer through these sites are often current release wines
with the occasional gem that can turn up if you hunt carefully. But you must do
your homework as most of these sites do not give an indication of the wines
secondary market value and quote RRP (recommended retail price) instead,
typically 40% more expensive.
A site such as Wine Searcher
can give you comparative values of what you should expect to pay at auction or
at retail.
Graysonline wine
Membership Cost: Free.
Auction Frequency: Daily
Buyer commission: 17.5% incl GST
Warranty: None (on private cellar sales)
Guaranteed provenance: No, but a detailed effort to disclose
it.
Shipping Costs: $? per lot. Consolidating shipping across sales is not
permitted.
Website: www.graysonline.com
Grays online
(sometimes known as Grays wine online or Greys wine) are a general auctioneer who trade many different types of goods as
well as having a wine section. A very well designed website, Grays provide the
buyer with a lot of information, however, on their fine wine (or private cellar
sales) Grays do not give a secondary market value of the lots which can often
result in far higher prices being paid by buyers not doing their homework rather
than as a result of fair demand for a particular wine.
Lawsons Menzies
Membership Cost: Free
Auction Frequency: Monthly
Buyer commission: 22% incl GST
Shipping Costs: Outsourced, quoted depending on winnings
Website: www.lawsonmenzies.com.au
A general, traditional auctioneer with a core business of art and bric-a-brac.
They hold fairly regular fine wine auctions and use fair secondary market
valuations in their catalogues.
Author: Mark Wickman
wineauction@wickman.net.au Google+ Profile